This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

❝

Every now and then we listen to podcasts with coaches from other sports and ask what their lessons might mean for field hockey. This is one of those pieces. The story comes from a baseball coach, Nick Mingione, in a podcast called “The Great Coaches” by Paul Barnett. The hockey bits come from our own coaches.

It's the autumn after Kentucky's first-ever College World Series, and Nick Mingione is looking at a mostly new squad. The first scrimmage is done, everyone's gathered in, and he asks them one question. In his words:

❝

"At the end of a practice, I might say, hey guys, who today was a great teammate today and why?"

Nick Mingione
Upgrade to Coach: watch the masterclasses on demand, plus Assistant.Hockey

Two players speak.

"we had a bunch of new players and only 2 people spoke." Nick goes home and tells his wife they've got a really long way to go. Then he does something I think most of us probably wouldn't. He asks the same question after the next scrimmage. And the one after that. Every scrimmage, all autumn long. "By the time we got to the end of the fall, Paul, they talked about each other for 7 and a half minutes."

Most coaches would probably file that under team bonding. Nick files it under something harder: what the coach, and then the players, are trained to notice.

❝

TL;DR

Nick Mingione, head baseball coach at the University of Kentucky, realised that after a strong first year he'd turned into a coach who mostly saw what his players did wrong, and he's honest enough to name that drift in himself. In hockey, Shea McAleese, David Harte and Emily Calderon each have their own version of the same idea: peer pairs and accountability buddies, praise in public and teach in private, one-on-one before the group. The books add the mechanism. Wade Gilbert explains why coaches drift towards hunting errors and why feedback after success matters, and Daniel Coyle's account of John Wooden's teaching gives us a sense of proportion. Where it all splits is on how much praise is too much. Nick floods his environment with thank-yous. Andreu Enrich says praise only shapes behaviour when it's earned and specific. We'll leave that one standing.

Sources

The coach who started seeing everything wrong

A quick word on who we're listening to. Nick has been head baseball coach at Kentucky since 2017. He took the programme to its first College World Series in 2024, won the SEC regular-season title that same year, and has twice been SEC Coach of the Year. He doesn't coach hockey, so he's the frame here. The hockey answers come from the hockey coaches.

What caught my ear in his conversation with Paul Barnett wasn't a drill. It was a confession about his own eye.

❝

"And I think sometimes in coaches, in coaching, we catch our players doing wrong. And Paul, the second year and the third and the fourth year, I started becoming the coach that started seeing my players do all the things wrong, when really my first year, why we had so much success is I was catching them doing good."

Nick Mingione

The thing that worked in year one quietly slipped away. In that first year, he says, "I was placing a high emphasis on the actions and the attitudes and the behaviors that we needed them to do". Then, somewhere along the line, the emphasis moved to everything that wasn't happening.

He mentions a friend, a college football coach, who calls himself the "detail coordinator", whose job is simply to notice the details. I like that, because it puts noticing on the job description. The question is which details.

This is where the books help, not to tell us what Nick should have done, but to explain why the drift is so common. Wade Gilbert, in Coaching Better Every Season, points out that coaches naturally look for errors. It's almost the default setting. We're trained to fix things, so we scan for what's broken. Gilbert also notes that athletes report more intrinsic motivation and a stronger sense of competence after feedback on their successful attempts than after feedback on their mistakes. His suggestion is to spread feedback deliberately between the two, rather than letting the error-hunting instinct decide for us.

So a book and a coach agree here. Nick found it the hard way, and Gilbert explains why it worked.

There's one more thing in Gilbert that I keep coming back to, though I want to be careful with it. He writes that athletes of emotionally exhausted coaches see them as less effective teachers who give less praise. Nick never says he was exhausted, and I'm not suggesting that's his explanation. But it does raise a question for the rest of us. When the season gets heavy, the results matter more and the to-do list gets longer, is that when our eye drifts towards the errors? And if it is, would we even notice?

❝

That's the problem. The rest of the piece is where the coaches come in. A student manager, a bucket and two words. Shea McAleese on how he hands the noticing over to his players, and his accountability buddies. David Harte and Emily Calderon on where praise goes and where corrections go. And a proper disagreement about how much praise is too much, which we don't settle. Plus three things you can try at your next session.

Try us at €5 /month for 3 months

Get 3 months full access for €5 /month to have access to the rest of this post and all our masterclasses, past, present and future :)

Try us for 3 months