Halfway through the season, most young players already know where they stand. They have counted their minutes, read the team sheet twice and worked out who gets picked for the short corner. What they rarely get is someone telling them, clearly and kindly, what is actually going on and what they can do about it.
That conversation is easy to put off. It feels risky with a 13- or 15-year-old, especially one who is short on confidence or short on game time. So it drifts into vague encouragement ("keep working hard, your chance will come"), or it gets saved for the end-of-season review, when nothing can change any more.
This article brings together what coaches and experts on The Hockey Site have said about honest feedback, video, confidence and individual goals. It turns that into a mid-season conversation you can actually have, and two training sessions that put it on the pitch in the same week.
TL;DR
Honest is not the same as hard. Tell young players where they stand, warmly and plainly, and give them one thing they control.
Ask before you tell. Let the emotion settle, listen first, then agree what happens next.
Make it concrete within the week: one behaviour, one clip, one private goal inside a normal training, and a date to review it.
The sources used to write this
Coachability with Shea McAleese
The Pygmalion effect with Andreu Enrich, Ric Charlesworth and David Harte
About Feedback, Anchor Tasks, Managing Arousal and so much more with Andreu Enrich
The video never lies with Robert Noall
Video analysis for youth coaches in field hockey with Emily Calderon
Confidence: a choice and a skill with Katie Warriner
A research based approach to talent development with David Passmore
How to stop young players quitting hockey, our earlier piece on enjoyment, grit and reflection routines
Why the halfway point matters
By mid-season, a young player has usually built a story about themselves. "I'm a bench player." "The coach doesn't rate me." "I'm only here because we're short." Once that story settles, it shapes how they train, how much they ask for the ball and whether they bother to fix anything. A player who has decided they are not a starter will often play like one.
Ric Charlesworth puts the cost of silence bluntly in The Pygmalion effect: "almost the worst thing you can do with a player is sit them on the bench and not use them, you know, because the message then is, I don't believe in you. I don't trust you." Young players read those signals constantly. If nobody explains them, they fill in the gaps themselves, and they rarely fill them in kindly.
Katie Warriner adds why this hits so hard at this age. In Confidence: a choice and a skill she warns about putting confidence "in sources that are out of our control, like results, like performance levels, like the feedback of a coach, whether or not I'm selected". That is exactly where most juniors put it. The mid-season conversation is a chance to move some of that confidence back to things they can influence.
Next up: Honest, not hard. Ask before you tell. Give them one thing they can control. Using video without making it a trial. Check who is getting your attention. Two sessions for your training. And finally 3 takeaways to apply immediately…
Try us at €5 /month for 3 months
Get 3 months full access for €5 /month to have access to the rest of this post and all our masterclasses, past, present and future :)
Try us for 3 months